Discontinuation of Human Subject Participation in Research.

On December 1, 2008, the HHS Office for Human Research Protections (OHRP), Office of Public Health and Science, announced it is requesting public comments on a draft guidance document entitled “Guidance on Important Considerations for When Participation of Human Subjects in Research is Discontinued.” The draft document is intended primarily for institutional review boards (IRBs), investigators, and funding agencies that may be responsible for the review or oversight of human subject research conducted or supported by HHS. OHRP will accept comments on the draft until January 30, 2009. In a related development, the FDA released guidance on “Data Retention When Subjects Withdraw from FDA-Regulated Clinical Trials,” which clarifies FDA's position that it is critical that data be retained from trial participants who decide to discontinue participation in a clinical study of an investigational product, who are withdrawn by their legally authorized representative, as applicable, or who were discontinued from participation by the clinical investigator. This Level 1 guidance is being issued for immediate implementation to prevent the potential loss of important clinical trial data.; if comments are received, the agency will review the comments and revise the guidance if appropriate. 

Guidance on Engagement of Institutions in HHS-Funded Human Subjects Research

The HHS Office for Human Research Protections has released its “Guidance on Engagement of Institutions in Human Subjects Research.” The guidance document describes whether certain scenarios would result in an institution being considered engaged in a human subjects research project, and addresses institutional review boards' review considerations for cooperative research in which multiple institutions are engaged in the same non-exempt human subjects research project. The guidance is intended primarily for IRBs, research administrators and other relevant institutional officials, investigators, and funding agencies that may be responsible for the conduct, review and oversight of human subject research that is conducted or supported by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. 

Medicare Routine Clinical Trial Costs

CMS has issued an educational article clarifying issues related to Medicare payment of certain routine costs associated with clinical trials. The article focuses on the prohibition on payment for items or services which neither the beneficiary nor any other person or organization has a legal obligation to pay (i.e., items and services furnished gratuitously without regard to the beneficiary’s ability to pay and without expectation of payment from any source, such as free x-rays or immunizations provided by health organizations). CMS discusses the application of this policy in three scenarios: when a research sponsor says it will pay for routine costs if there is no reimbursement from any insurance company; when a research sponsor pays for the routine costs provided to an indigent non-Medicare patient; and when a research sponsor pays Medicare copayments for beneficiaries in a clinical trial. 

Health Policy Legislation Moves Through Congress

There has been a flurry of recent legislative activity as the 110th Congress prepares to adjourn in the coming days. Congress has taken action on a wide range of health policy bills, addressing such issues as FDA drug and device approvals, internet pharmacy regulation, health care workforce issues, insurance coverage, and medical treatment, and patent protection for antibiotics.   Specifically, the following legislation has been approved by the House and Senate and now await the President’s signature:

  • H.R. 6353, the “Ryan Haight Online Pharmacy Consumer Protection Act,” which would prohibit the sale of controlled substances over the Internet without a valid prescription and subject on-line pharmacies to a series of new restrictions.
  • S. 3560, the “QI Program Supplemental Funding Act,” which would authorize an additional $45 million for the Medicare Qualifying Individuals (QI) program, which helps certain low-income individuals pay their Medicare Part B premiums. The legislation also includes provisions to modify the patent protections applicable to antibiotics and clarify the ability of generic drug companies to gain approval of and market generic antibiotics. In addition, the bill would expand the education activities under the Medicaid Integrity Program (MIP) and extend funding for the Medicare Improvement Fund to make improvements under the original Medicare program. 
  • Several measures aimed at expanding disease research and information resources, including: H.R. 1157, which would authorize grants for the development and operation of research centers for the study of environmental factors that may be related to the etiology of breast cancer; H.R. 1532, which would reauthorize the Preventive Health Services Regarding Tuberculosis program; H.R. 5265, which would promote research into the causes and treatments of various forms of Muscular Dystrophy; S. 1810, to authorize the HHS Secretary to collect and disseminate information regarding Down syndrome or other prenatally or postnatally diagnosed diseases and to coordinate the provision of support services for those who receive a diagnosis of one of those diseases; and S. 1382, which would authorize funding for the establishment of a national registry for the collection and storage of data on amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS).

 

  • S. 2932, which would reauthorize the poison center national toll-free number, provide grants for poison centers, and expand poison prevention education efforts.
  • S. 1760, which would reauthorize the Healthy Start Initiative, which provides grants to reduce infant mortality and improve maternal health.
  • H.R. 1343, which would provide funding to enable health centers to serve medically underserved populations and reauthorize the National Health Service Corps Scholarship and Loan Repayment programs.

In addition, the following bills have been approved by the House but are awaiting Senate action.

  • H.R. 1014, the Heart Disease Education, Analysis Research, and Treatment (HEART) for Women Act, which would require new drug, biologics, and device applications submitted to FDA to include any clinical data possessed by the sponsor that relates to safety or effectiveness by gender, age, and racial subgroups. This information would be posted on the internet. The bill also would authorize research and public health activities to reduce cardiovascular disease in women. 
  • H.R. 6908, the “HIPAA Recreational Injury Technical Correction Act,” which would require timely disclosure of limitations and restrictions on coverage under group health plans.
  • H.R. 758, which would require health insurers to cover minimum lengths of stay and secondary consultations for patients undergoing procedures to treat and diagnose breast cancer.
  • H.R. 2583, the “Physician Workforce and Graduate Medical Education Enhancement Act ,” which would authorize a loan repayment program for hospitals to start a residency training program.
  • H.R. 6568, which would expand research and educational activities related to pulmonary hypertension.
  • H.R. 2994, which would direct the Department of Health and Human Services to establish a national pain care education outreach and awareness campaign.
  • H.R. 6469, which would increase funding for the Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network.
  • H.R. 5352, the “Elder Abuse Victims Act,” which would establish specialized elder abuse prosecution and research programs and activities to aid victims of elder abuse, provide training to prosecutors and other law enforcement related to elder abuse prevention and protection.
  • H.R. 6901, which would improve treatment for methamphetamine addiction.

FDA Guidance: Bioequivalence (BE) Recommendations and Drug Clinical Trials

The FDA has announced the availability of additional draft and revised draft product-specific guidance on the design of BE studies to support abbreviated new drug applications (ANDAs). FDA will accept comments on the recommendations until December 4, 2008. Separately, the FDA has released draft guidance entitled “M3(R2) Nonclinical Safety Studies for the Conduct of Human Clinical Trials and Marketing Authorization for Pharmaceuticals.'' The document, which discusses the types of nonclinical studies and their relation to the conduct of human clinical trials and marketing authorization for pharmaceuticals, is intended to facilitate the timely conduct of clinical trials and reduce the unnecessary use of animals and other drug development resources. The FDA is requesting comments on the draft guidance by October 20, 2008.